The Poetics of Despair: Jonas Kaufmann, Sophie Koch, and the Met’s 2014 Werther
The staging of Jules Massenet’s Werther at the Metropolitan Opera, captured live in 2014 under the visionary direction of Richard Eyre, stands as an enduring monument to late-romantic theatricality and musical refinement. In this masterclass of operatic psychology, the demanding title role of the tortured poet Werther is entrusted to Jonas Kaufmann, an artist whose vocal and physical identification with the character borders on the absolute. By the time of this production, Kaufmann had already refined his interpretation of Massenet’s tragic hero on international stages, moving effortlessly from his earlier, lighter lyrical footing into the heavier, more baritonal weights of the dramatic French and Italian repertoires. He possesses an innate theatrical magnetism, and even under the unforgiving scrutiny of cinematic close-ups, his portrayal of the young, all-consuming lover is utterly convincing, radiating a profound, melancholic vulnerability. Vocally, Kaufmann’s instrument has evolved far beyond a standard lyric tenor configuration; while it occasionally carries a baritonal thickness and moments of heavy pressure in the lower register, these characteristics lend an authentic, world-weary desperation to the character's downward spiral. His management of the French legato line is handled with immense expressive intelligence, effortlessly floating exquisite, hushed pianissimos in "Pourquoi me réveiller?" that reduce the massive auditorium of the Met to an absolute, breathless silence.
Opposite Kaufmann, Sophie Koch as Charlotte anchors the psychological architecture of the tragedy with a commanding dignity and vocal opulence. Koch, renowned for her profound affinity for French romantic roles, brings a rich, dark-hued mezzo-soprano that effortlessly balances the domestic duties imposed upon Charlotte by her father with the subterranean fires of her illicit passion for Werther. Her stage pres
The civic and domestic periphery of the opera is anchored by a stellar gallery of character portrayals. Jonathan Summers as the Bailiff brings a robust, authoritative baritone and a genial, paternal warmth to the role, establishing the ordered, bourgeois stability of Wetzlar that Werther’s chaotic soul finds so suffocating. The tavern companions Johann and Schmidt—portrayed with wonderful comic timing and vocal resonance by Philip Cokorinos and Tony Stevenson respectively—provide a vital foil to the romantic anguish, injecting a dose of earthy realism into the fabric of the community. Meanwhile, David Bižić embodies Albert with an uncompromising, stiff-backed nobility. Bižić possesses a dark, resonant baritone that projects unwavering civic righteousness and unyielding marital claim; his portrayal avoids simple villainy, presenting Albert instead as an honorable, decent man tragically unequipped to comprehend the poetic cyclone that has invaded his household. The children’s chorus and smaller supporting roles, including Christopher Job’s Brühlmann and Maya Lahyani’s Käthchen, execute their framing duties with meticulous discipline. In the orchestra pit, conductor Alain Altinoglu guides the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra with an acute sensitivity to Massenet’s shimmering, highly colored orchestration, drawing out the lush string textures and sighing woodwinds while meticulously supporting the emotional arcs of the soloists.
The Olympic Triumph of Baroque Virtuosity: Jakub Jozef Orlinski and Marina Viotti in Venice
The grand intersection of athletic metaphor and high baroque musical execution found a breathtaking realization in the much-anticipated performance featuring countertenor Jakub Jozef Orlinski and mezzo-soprano Marina Viotti, alongside the crystalline soprano Katerina. This extraordinary event brought together some of the most magnetic and technically fearless interpreters of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century repertoire, transforming the stage into a modern amphitheater of vocal endurance, agility, and emotional resonance. Following the stylistic model of deep musicological inquiry and exhaustive character analysis, this presentation explores a landscape where the rigorous demands of Vivaldi’s vocal writing are met with an uncompromising theatricality. The vocal burden of the evening rests firmly upon the contrasting yet complementary timbres of Orlinski and Viotti, whose stylistic evolution from lighter, agile early baroque chamber works to monumental heroic and tragic operatic roles has established them as absolute titans of contemporary period performance.
Jakub Jozef Orlinski commands the stage with an athletic brilliance and a luminous, honeyed countertenor that defies conventional vocal limitations. By the time of this performance, he had made significant technical and interpretive strides from his earlier, lighter lyrical footing into complex, emotionally volatile heroic roles. He possesses an innate, electrifying stage presence, and his physical dynamism—enhanced by his renowned background in breakdancing—translates into a fluid, gravity-defying mastery of rapid-fire coloratura and breath control. Vocally, his voice retains its youthful agility while acquiring a richer, more burnished resonance in the lower and middle registers. While there are occasional moments of slight tonal edge under extreme pressure or when navigating dizzying, acrobatic interval leaps, thes
The supporting instrumental forces and vocal collaborators demonstrate a deep, instinctive familiarity with the idiom of Antonio Vivaldi and his contemporaries, making various admirable efforts in terms of ornamentation and rhetorical declamation. The orchestral execution under the primary baton approaches the score with a pulsing, athletic energy, developing dramatic tension by respecting the needs of the soloists while honoring Vivaldi's finely crafted, rhythmically charged instrumentation. The string sections play with a crisp, muscular articulation that evokes the dynamic friction of athletic competition, driving the allegros forward with relentless momentum while allowing the slow lamentation movements to breathe with profound, elegiac sorrow. Neither the physical staging nor the complex narrative architecture allows any performer to hide behind passive technical display; every singer is required to look, play, and characterize their role continuously throughout the musical line, and they do so with admirable dedication. Katerina, Orlinski, and Viotti unite virtuosic fearlessness with deep psychological truth, resulting in an unforgettable triumph of baroque interpretation.
The Twilight Splendor of Vienna’s Burggarten: An Operatic Summons
The vocal architecture and dramatic breadth of the open-air gala presented by the Vienna State Opera in the historic Burggarten, set against the monumental backdrop of the Neue Hofburg, revolves around an extraordinary quartet of world-class soloists whose careers have continually expanded into heavier, psychologically demanding territory. In an outdoor setting before a crowd of thousands, the challenges of projection, amplification balance, and atmospheric concentration are notoriously perilous. Yet, under the seasoned leadership of Marco Armiliato at the helm of the Orchester der Wiener Staatsoper, this season-opening showcase transcends the typical light gala fare, turning into a rigorous exploration of nineteenth-century verismo, French romanticism, bel canto fire, and late-romantic grandeur.
The vocal core among the female roles belongs to Asmik Grigorian. By the time of this performance, she has traversed a remarkable artistic trajectory from lighter lyric heroines to the volcanic heights of Salome, Rusalka, and Jenůfa, establishing herself as one of the most intense singing-actresses of our era. She has always possessed an arresting theatrical magnetism, and even on an open-air festival stage with cameras capturing every minute flicker of expression, she portrays each character with absolute, unsparing commitment. Opening the concert with the Habanera from Bizet's Carmen, Grigorian does not treat the piece as an over-polished salon tune; instead, she invests it with a smoky, languid defiance, reacting to the audience and the orchestral phrases with subtle, dangerous irony. Vocally, her instrument is no longer a light, crystalline lyric soprano; it has taken on a dusky, penetrating core with a formidable middle register capable of cutting cleanly into the night air. While there are moments where her tone carries an incisive, almost razor-sharp bite in the upper transition, these accents serve th
Beczala's command of the German romantic repertoire is showcased in "In fernem Land" from Wagner's Lohengrin. Here, his vocal placement remains pristine and focused, marrying radiant lyrical beauty with an aristocratic, sacred nobility. The gradual crescendo from mystical contemplation to the ringing declaration of the Grail knight’s identity is constructed with masterly pacing, proving that his transition into the heavier German fach has compromised none of his pristine diction or flexible legato. In the climactic finale of Puccini's "Nessun dorma" from Turandot, Beczala commands the vast park with heroic brilliance, ringing out the climactic high B with a triumphant ease that electrifies the tens of thousands in attendance.
The lower male register is commanded by the peerless French baritone Ludovic Tézier, widely regarded as the foremost Verdi baritone of his generation. Tézier is an artist who has ascended to the pinnacle of dramatic roles—from Iago and Scarpia to Rigoletto and Macbeth—while maintaining an impeccable noble line derived from classical French vocal training. In Renato’s great monologue and aria "Alzati! … Eri tu che macchiavi quell’anima" from Verdi's Un ballo in maschera, Tézier delivers a clinic in psychological declamation. The initial recitative boils with wounded dignity and murderous rage, delivered with a dark, terrifying authority, before yielding to the aching sorrow of the cantabile. His ability to spin a continuous, velvet-smooth legato line, shaded with subtle dynamic gradations and profound melancholy, makes this performance an absolute benchmark. Later, in Macbeth’s desolate "Pietà, rispetto, amore", Tézier captures the tragic hollow emptiness of a tyrant who realizes the absolute futility of his blood-soaked crown. His bronze-toned resonance and aristocratic vocal restraint avoid melodrama, turning the aria into a heartbreaking meditation on mortality.
Injecting an entirely different, dazzling energy into the program, Juan Diego Fló
Holding this vast musical kaleidoscope together is conductor Marco Armiliato, directing the Orchester der Wiener Staatsoper with seasoned theatrical wisdom and instinctive flexibility. In an outdoor gala where diverse stylistic worlds collide in rapid succession, Armiliato never allows the orchestra to become a mere metronomic backing track. He develops the drama by scrupulously respecting the individual breathing and pacing needs of each singer, whether creating a suspended, translucent hush for Grigorian’s vulnerable pianissimos or giving full rein to the thunderous brass and percussion during Giordano’s and Puccini’s grandest climaxes. The Vienna State Opera orchestra responds with its customary warmth, opulent string sheen, and characterful woodwind colors. Together, these artists deliver far more than a celebratory public concert: they offer a masterclass in the living art of opera, proving that even outside the hallowed walls of the theater, the profound union of voice, orchestra, and dramatic text remains an unconquerable cultural force.
Video 2013_Falstaff_A_Stellar_Cast_Levine_Verdi_at_His_Wittiest.mp · 1684.2 MB · click to show
The Mid-Century Merrymaking of Verdi’s Falstaff at the Met
Robert Carsen’s acclaimed 2013 Metropolitan Opera production of Giuseppe Verdi’s comic masterpiece Falstaff reimagines Shakespeare’s Windsor through a stylish, post-war English lens. Ambrogio Maestri commands the stage as an inimitable, vocally opulent Sir John Falstaff, supported by a world-class ensemble featuring Angela Meade as Alice Ford, Stephanie Blythe as a riotous Mistress Quickly, and Lisette Oropesa as an enchanting, silvery-voiced Nannetta. Paolo Fanale (Fenton), Franco Vassallo (Ford), Jennifer Johnson Cano (Meg Page), Keith Jameson (Bardolfo), and Christian Van Horn (Pistola) complete the stellar cast. In the pit, Music Director James Levine leads the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra and Chorus in a vibrant, transparent, and rhythmically exhilarating reading of Verdi’s final score.